Grade "A" Architecture

Home > golf mechanics > Grade "A" Architecture
The Dormie Club
Estimated reading time: 4 minutes

West End, North Carolina, USA
17th Hole / 499 Yards / Par-5
Architect: Bill Coore & Ben Crenshaw (2010)

Architecture - The Dormie Club
The 17th hole brilliantly showcases the creative genius of Bill Coore and Ben Crenshaw in demonstrating how a par-5 of less than 500 yards must be reconciled

Estimated reading time: 5 minutes


The positioning of the penultimate hole on any golf course is a crucial one. Matches between players are reaching a conclusion and having an edge before reaching the tee at the 18th hole is something players want desperately.

Par-5 holes are routinely viewed by players as an easy prey for birdies and, on first glance, when someone looks at the scorecard for The Dormie Club and sees a 499-yard hole listed it is not uncommon for players to believe that a prime scoring opportunity awaits.

Guess again.

The architectural rendering shows clearly the strategic implications golfers face with the "chain reaction" center-placed bunker menacingly standing guard


The renowned designs of Bill Coore and Ben Crenshaw rightly pride themselves in creating holes that are anything but obvious. The 17th at The Dormie Club will not succumb to false bravado -- only committed strategies in conjunction with flawless execution will succeed.

The hole commences with a slightly uphill tee shot with a fairway moving gently from right-to-left. 

Bunkers bracket the landing area on both sides and the placements are varied. Strong players can contemplate a bold play in attempting to fly a ball over the left corner. That line of play requires a 280-yard carry over a protecting bunker to an uphill landing area. It's not for the faint of heart and C&C are not about to have the hole surrender without putting up a fight. Generally, players will also encounter a prevailing headwind so the need for absolute commitment to such a perilous line of attack needs to be thought about with the utmost respect.

The real pressure happens on the 2nd shot.

As you gaze ahead you see the putting surface perched high on a rise. The Holy Grail indeed.

The hole is ably defended by a menacing waste area guarding the pathway to the green -- projecting a fierce presence similar to a growling guard dog at a junkyard. The waste area is approximately 35 yards in length and eager to grab the hapless or foolish golfer who does not respect the disaster that waits for those caught in its clutches. 

Architecture - The Dormie Club
The waste bunker presents a formidable challenge -- does one heroically carry it on the second shot or prudently lay-up before it?

The area is fashioned to replicate what golfers face when playing Pine Valley's famed par-5 7th and its accompanying "Hell's Half Acre." Balls that finish within its confines face the most terrifying of situations -- the dreaded long bunker shot. And there is always the possibility that a ball may not have the best of stances or the freedom from any internal complications such as wild grasses that grow within its boundary. 

Central to success at the 17th is finding the fairway. The carry of the cross-bunker means being able to hit two shots in excess of 450 yards. No small feat for sure.

In addition, C&C have narrowed the available landing area for those considering a play to get to the far side of the waste area. Only the select few can contemplate going for the green in two blows. In short -- the reward is there for the taking but the risk factor is front and center too.

For most players the more sensible second shot will be played short of the waste area -- leaving a third shot in the range of 90-110 yards.

Architecture - The Dormie Club
The penultimate hole rises in elevation for the tee shot and most noticeably as one nears the green in the distance

The approach to the 17th is ably defended -- a false front awaits the timid of plays and will quickly inflict pain in pulling back one's golf ball. The green is 33 yards in depth but sloped perilously on a back-to-front tilt. There is a small cut-out section for a pin position on the right side. There is also a slight back tier area where a devilish pin position can be located. Missing to either side of the green will mean the highest of skills needed with one's short game.

In the world of golf -- there are great par-5s occupying the penultimate position. Among the key clubs are Baltusrol Lower in New Jersey, Muirfield in Scotland and Riviera in the greater Los Angeles area, to name just a few.

The 17th at The Dormie Club checks all the key boxes. Eye-catching scenery in concert with strategic calculations of the highest order. 

Success is indeed achievable but the reward must always be earned. 


Photos and rendering courtesy of The Dormie Club


Avatar photo

About M. James Ward

A GWAA and MGWA member, the 66-year-old from the USA has covered golf in all facets since 1980, notably the major championships and other high level events. He has played over 2,000 courses globally and has competed in USGA Championships.

Join the discussion

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Read Next

Investec South African Open Championship 2023 R1

Joakim Lagergren shoots best round since Spring to take lead

Investec South African Open Championship R1
ISPS HANDA Australian Open 2023 R1

Cam Davis takes opening lead in Australia

ISPS HANDA Australian Open R1
Ukrainian junior golfers’ visit to Scotland ‘has changed their lives’

Ukrainian junior golfers’ visit to Scotland ‘has changed their lives’

The seven players came together for the first time to take part in the Project Ukraine golf camp.
Luke Donald

Luke Donald humbled by players’ support for his return as Ryder Cup captain

Donald has been reappointed after masterminding a commanding victory in Rome earlier this year.
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram